Useful Articles

image

“Can I speak to Kate Wilkinson?” That’s how a call to our office began on...

4 years ago News

“Can I speak to Kate Wilkinson?” That’s how a call to our office began on...

“Can I speak to Kate Wilkinson?”


That’s how a call to our office began on Monday. Our receptionist told the caller I wasn’t at my desk – I was actually on Radio 702  discussing farm murder rates.


When he heard I was unavailable, the caller started shouting down the line about my research on farm attacks.


“Murderers!” he screamed. “Murderers!”


Another march to protest farm murders




This Saturday AfriForum, a non-governmental organisation which seeks to protect “the rights of minorities” with “a specific focus on the rights of Afrikaners”, will march to South Africa’s Union Buildings. It plans to deliver a memorandum about farm murders and attacks in South Africa to the president.


Last month, thousands of protesters gathered around the country in a similar protest called “BlackMonday”.


Deputy CEO of AfriForum, Ernst Roets,  claims that “farmers are tortured to death on farms in unusual ratios”. The “ratio” that he refers to is the farmer murder rate, presented as the number of farmers murdered per 100, 000 of them in South Africa.


I have seen a number of different farm murder rates during my time at Africa Check.


There was the 133 per 100, 000 cited by the Freedom Front Plus’ Pieter Groenewald. The African Christian Democratic Party’s Steve Swart and the Institute for Security Studies’ Johan Burger pegged it lower at 97 per 100, 000.



Calculating farmer murder rate ‘near impossible’



AfriForum added a new farmer murder rate last month.



Their new rate of 156 commercial farmers being murdered out of every 100, 000 in the country was reported on by Times LIVE. The news story claimed that “commercial farmers are 4.5 times as likely to get murdered as the South African population as a whole”.


In May this year, I spoke to numerous crime experts, the South African police and trade unions to determine if any farm murder rate was accurate. The conclusion? The numbers being circulated are flawed and we don’t have enough data to calculate an accurate estimate. At the moment calculating a farmer murder rate is “near impossible”.


This is because there are numerous problems with the data. One: farm murders are probably undercounted, experts say. Two: we don’t know exactly how many farmers there are in South Africa and therefore we can’t calculate the rate.


That farmers are victims of violent attacks is not in question. What is in doubt is their risk in relation to the average South African.



Distributing flawed stats – knowingly


So my first reaction when I saw AfriForum’s new commercial farmer murder rate was curiosity.


“How was it calculated?” I thought. “Do they have access to new data?”


I emailed Roets. Curiosity turned to dismay when he responded.


Roets told me that their new statistic “is the same calculation that was already dealt with on Africa Check [sic], but calculated for the year 2016”. In other words, they’ve distributed a statistic that they know has been calculated in a flawed manner.


Roets did not respond to further questions on the calculation of the figure.



Farm attacks are horrific



If I had been in the office to take that angry call on Monday I would have said the following:


I have great sympathy for the dangers people in rural areas encounter. I know too well the fear that these communities face.


I grew up on a farm in Northern KwaZulu-Natal. I know people who have been brutally tortured in farm attacks. In one case, a family friend had the soles of his feet boiled off. He is always in my thoughts when I work on this topic. It’s an image you cannot erase from your mind.


Saying that accuracy and statistical honesty is important is not the same as saying that farm attacks aren’t horrific.


My question is: Does AfriForum care about getting farm murder statistics right? Because at the moment they are being dishonest. They are knowingly sharing numbers that have been calculated with a flawed methodology. They have admitted as much.


Africa Check has meticulously collected and published the available farm murder and attack research, but as with any topic we research, we don’t have the monopoly on it.


Our aim is to enable accurate and informed debate – and advocacy – on the topic. The best publically available data is easy to access and understand in our factsheet. We explain what the research can and can’t tell you in my analysis.


If AfriForum truly cares about their cause they should care about getting the statistics right. They need to be honest with numbers. They need to be honest with the public.


This report was written by Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher at Africa Check, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. Follow them on Facebook and Twitter for more groundbreaking stories.


More Appsa News Updates:

just now News

Midrand ReporterTruck overturns in Blue Hills16 Days of Activism: 16 ways you ca

Read More
4 years ago News

A truck overturned on Olifantsfontein Road outside the Blue Hills Shopping Centr

Read More
4 years ago News

As South Africa observes 16 Days of Activism opposing Violence Against Women and

Read More
4 years ago News

“Can I speak to Kate Wilkinson?” That’s how a call to our off

Read More
4 years ago News

For the first time ever, Scottish alternative pop/rock sensation Texas will perf

Read More
4 years ago News

16 Days of Activism Against Gender-Based Violence is an organizing strategy by i

Read More
4 years ago News

Summerhill Preparatory School children participated in the National Eisteddfod o

Read More
4 years ago News

Shoppers around the world will ‘go bonkers’ for Black Friday today,

Read More
4 years ago News

Summerhill School participated in the Story Skirmish junior version of the &lsqu

Read More
4 years ago News

Midrand Police Station has conducted several awareness campaigns to increase vig

Read More
4 years ago News

There is no doubt that the advancement of technology has changed the way the wor

Read More
4 years ago News

The price of gold reaching $1 000 an ounce in 2009 unleashed a modern day g

Read More
4 years ago News

In an effort to reduce the number of drownings over the festive season, City of

Read More
4 years ago News

Online exclusive Statistics of abuse in South Africa remain extremely high desp

Read More
4 years ago News

Heino Gevers, customer experience manager at Mimecast South Africa, writes: Sou

Read More

Latest News:

Western Cape 4 years ago
Former Western Cape Police Commissioner, Arno Lamoer, looking relaxed prior to sentencing in the...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Police Minister Bheki cele responds to an outcry by students from Tshwane University of Technology i
South Africa 4 years ago
When an allergy becomes a medical emergency. Most allergic reactions can be successfully treated at...
South Africa 4 years ago
Sandton: Pedestrian injured after being knocked down by vehicle on Leslie Avenue in Douglasdale,...
Western Cape 4 years ago
Police have prevented a potentially violent confrontation between rival taxi associations in...
Western Cape 4 years ago
President Cyril Ramaphosa says he's deeply concerned about America's decision to withdraw from the...
Western Cape 4 years ago
Former Western Cape Police Commissioner, Arno Lamoer and three co-accused are set to be sentenced in...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: Traditional leadership rural policing strategy to be piloted in Eastern Cape The East
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: Joint rural policing strategy to be piloted in Eastern Cape Zwelitsha: The Eastern C
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: : Immediate response by the members of Bethelsdorp police station to a complaint of b
South Africa 4 years ago
Netcare 911 Hawker Jet Air Ambulance at King Shaka International Airport
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: Serial rapist handed 5 life sentences, Nelson Mandela Bay NELSON MANDELA BAY: 30 ye
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: Police embark in door to door campaign in Kabega Park Port Elizabeth: A Door to door
South Africa 4 years ago
National Renal Care (NRC) & Netcare St Anne's Hospital have established a new support group for...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Western Cape: Suspects arrested for possession of drugs in Mitchells Plain The Mitchells Plain Cri
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: Joint rural policing strategy underway at Provincial Head Quarters The Eastern Cape P
Western Cape 4 years ago
Patricia de Lille has reported for work at the City Council this morning, saying she's still the...
Western Cape 4 years ago
Six people have been injured in a head-on collision between a bakkie and a car in Grassy Park. ER-24...
Western Cape 4 years ago
The ANC in the Western Cape says the DA's decision to remove Patricia de Lille from her position as...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Arrests made following public violence. Limpopo - Four (4) people aged between 32 and 64 were on Tu
South Africa 4 years ago
At you will find comprehensive, sound guidance on how to handle a host of...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Off duty Police officer foils armed robbery. #ServiceExcellence Limpopo: "When Duty Calls" was put
South Africa 4 years ago
High blood pressure and salt intake. South Africa has one of the highest rates of Hypertension in...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Suspects arrested by Manenberg police for serious crimes. #CrimeMustFall Western Cape: Our continue
Western Cape 4 years ago
Patricia de Lille insists that she remains the Mayor of Cape Town. This after the DA's Federal...
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Illegal hunter gets R1 million fine for rhino poaching. Limpopo - The Provincial Commissioner of th
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Mpumalanga: Provincial Commissioner concerned by unbecoming Conduct of Police members NELSPRUIT
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: Eastern Cape: SAPS Mount Road hosted an outreach at the Môrewag Primary School, Kensington. A day o
South Africa 4 years ago
SAPS NEWS: KwaZulu-Natal: Update: Three Suspects in Court following stadium violence Durban: Three suspects ap
Western Cape 4 years ago
A woman has been taken in for questioning following a fire in Khayelitsha on the Cape Flats which...