Useful Articles

image

VanBreda: Evidence presented by State of poor quality, says defense...

1 week ago South Africa

VanBreda: Evidence presented by State of poor quality, says defense...

VanBreda: Evidence presented by State of poor quality, says defense

Cape Town - Defence advocate Piet Botha told the Western Cape High Court on Tuesday that the State failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt in the trial of triple murder accused Henri Van Breda.
He said the State's case was based on speculation, "inferences should be drawn from facts", and that evidence presented by the State was of "poor quality".
Twenty three-year-old Van Breda has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder, one of attempted murder and one of obstructing the ends of justice.
It is the State's case that he attacked his family with an axe, and that his sister Marli, who was 16 at the time, survived the attack - not as a result of a lesser attack, but rather because of a "miracle".
The attack in the family home in the De Zalze, Stellenbosch security estate in 2015 shocked the country, and the sensational trial has dominated headlines for more than 60 days.
The defence has its final stab at convincing the court of Van Breda's version, that a laughing, axe-wielding intruder was behind the attack, and that the "State did not prove its case beyond reasonable doubt".
Botha said "what the court needs to decide is the identity of the attackers".
He said there was an attempt by the State to create the impression that the Van Breda home was impenetrable, that nothing appeared to be stolen, there had been no breach of the perimeters, that a heated argument on January 26 from 10pm until midnight had preceded the attacks, and that unlike the rest of his family, Van Breda had suffered superficial injuries that were self-inflicted.
"One can speculate, one can say the dog was in the garage, one can say he smoked cigarettes while waiting for his sister to die. One can convince oneself that the State has made out a strong case. The onus is on the State, not on the accused, to prove its case. We submit that the conclusion cannot be that the State proved itself beyond doubt. The actual evidence points the other way, or at the very least creates reasonable doubt."
He said the accused had made a "good witness" and had not deviated from his version of events.
Botha argued that the circumstantial evidence presented by the State supported the accused's narrative and not the State's.
"The circumstantial evidence presented by the State to prove its case against the accused does not warrant, as the only reasonable inference, that the accused was the person who attacked his family."

https://www.msn.com/en-za/news/featured/supernumbervanbreda-evidence-presented-by-state-of-poor-quality-says-defense/ar-BBJ4lkj?ocid=st

More Appsa News Updates:

2 hours ago South Africa

Gigaba grilled over Gupta links | IOL Business Report

Read More
2 hours ago South Africa

Suspect arrested in connection with albinism murder, kidnapping

Read More
11 hours ago South Africa

More than 100 girls 'missing' after Boko Haram school attack

Read More
13 hours ago South Africa

Businessman murdered in front of 11-year-old son

Read More
14 hours ago South Africa

Olive is back on the beat LIFEWednesday 21 February 2018 - 6:31pm In the early hours of Wednesday...

Read More
16 hours ago South Africa

Pretoria North cop shot dead while asleep in his home

Read More
16 hours ago South Africa

Cape Town - The North Gauteng High Court has ruled that Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba lied under...

Read More
16 hours ago South Africa

Influential US preacher Billy Graham dies

Read More
16 hours ago South Africa

VERY SAD UPDATE: The bodies of 13-year-old Gabisile Shabani and the 15-month-old Nkosikhona Welcome...

Read More
17 hours ago South Africa

16:02 21/02/2018 Tammy Petersen Cape Town – Convicted murderer Johannes Plaatjies on Wednesday...

Read More
17 hours ago South Africa

‘Man overheard three plotting’ - HeraldLIVE

Read More
17 hours ago South Africa

Teenager ambushed, left for dead on the way to school - HeraldLIVE

Read More
22 hours ago South Africa

Cash-strapped Jason Rohde fires three of his four lawyers - HeraldLIVE

Read More
23 hours ago South Africa

Eastern Cape cop murders: Team of top detectives appointed 35 minutes ago Lizeka Tandwa Johannesburg...

Read More
23 hours ago South Africa

SIX police officers have been killed by unknown gunmen at Ngcobo police station in the Eastern Cape....

Read More

Latest News:

South Africa 18 mins ago
#sapsGP Two suspects were arrested next to Mall of the South in Johannesburg following a shooting incident that left a security guard fatally wounded on 21/02. ME
South Africa 33 mins ago
R1.8 Million Rands Worth Of Frozen Meat Recovered in Mt. Edgecombe, KZN - Truck and Freight Information Online
South Africa 25 mins ago
8 People injured as a minibus taxi rolls on the R21 southbound before the Olifantsfontein exit in the Centurion
South Africa 33 mins ago
[WESTONARIA] - Three injured after two-vehicle collision. - ER24
South Africa 52 mins ago
Seven firearms recovered in Osizweni, five suspects were arrested in KwaZulu-Natal | Road Safety Blog
South Africa 50 mins ago
Don’t let Roadside Distractions endanger your Safety! Remain Alert when you Drive, Ride, Walk and...
South Africa 42 mins ago
Three suspects arrested with the possession mandrax tablets valued at R 50 000 | Don't Drink and Drive
South Africa 56 mins ago
TSHWANE: Paramedics from several services are attending to a minibus taxi that rolled on the R21...
South Africa 55 mins ago
RANDBURG AREA: 1 Person has been injured in a crash on the N1 southbound before the Malibongwe exit.
South Africa 55 mins ago
greeting my name is solly mabote and im 33yeard of age and i reside in empumalanga pplace called...
Cape Town 1 hour ago
Update: Stationary vehicle on Sir Lowry's Pass inbound at Lookout Point has been cleared.
South Africa 17 hours ago
Slight increase in national dams
South Africa 1 hour ago
Transformational policies can address Africa’s challenges
South Africa 1 hour ago
VAT needed to be increased to stabilise debt
South Africa 56 mins ago
One killed, 16 injured after head-on collision in Meyerton One person died and 16 others sustained...
South Africa 2 hours ago
President Ramaphosa tees off for charity
South Africa 2 hours ago
France congratulates President Ramaphosa
Durban 52 mins ago
HIGH SCHOOL LEARNER CAUGHT IN POSSESSION OF R50 000 FAKE R100 NOTES LIKE our page SPICE Mag A high...
South Africa 56 mins ago
#sapsEC King Williams Town: Yesterday, a #SAPS tracing team conducted an intell driven op in Tolofiyeni Location. 2 Suspects wanted icw housebreaking & theft arrested. The will appear at Zwelitsha Magistrate’s Court soon. ME
South Africa 1 hour ago
LONEHILL: Collision with injuries at Lonehill Boulevard and Main Road.
South Africa 1 hour ago
HILLBROW: 2 Shot, 1 in a critical condition, following an apparent robbery in Smit Street last...
South Africa 1 hour ago
The last BMW 3 Series Sedan produced at the BMW Group | Car Insurance
South Africa 1 hour ago
Missing Search And Rescue K9
South Africa 1 hour ago
CAREER OPPORTUNITIES: AEA - ER24 Industrial Sites Clinical Coordinator - Contact Centre Quality...
South Africa 1 hour ago
In other news: Pupils from Thomo-Hlomela haven't attended schools this morning following the heavy...
South Africa 1 hour ago
Farm murder suspect killed in attempted farm attack. One of the four suspects in the Herman Botha...
South Africa 1 hour ago
Do taxi drivers sit and advice each other like, " guys we must stop driving sh&t"
South Africa 1 hour ago
#sapsEC #Ngcobo: #SAPS Top Management from Nt'l Head Office & Prov Office are visiting families of our fallen heroes today. A high caliber Task team was assembled comprising of Detectives, #Hawks, Crime intelligence, Tracing team, TRT to investigate t
South Africa 1 hour ago
#sapsGP Ekurhuleni West Cluster, Thokoza #SAPS visited Nqubela Primary School as part of the #SaferSchools Programme aiming to educate learners about various topics incl #SayNOtoBullying & #SayNOtoDrugs & how to report abuse. ME
Western Cape 1 hour ago
#ServiceRecovery underway. Signal power failure between Maitland and Hazendal restored. #CapeFlatsLineCT trains will operate normal route with residual delays of 20 - 30 min.